Why is montresor an unreliable narrator? (2022)

Asked by: Glenda Gaylord

Score: 4.1/5 (57 votes)

Montresor is considered an unreliable narrator because his opinion of Fortunato is biased. ... The audience to whom Montresor is narrating the story is not defined. The fact that this story is told from the first person allows the reader to believe and even trust the descriptions and actions of Montresor.

How do we know Montresor is unreliable?

As an audience, we can recognize that Montresor is an unreliable character by questioning his acute memory of spoken words and actions that he specifically recalls on a night that happened 50 years ago.

Can you trust the Montresor as the narrator Why or why not?

Montresor is an unreliable narrator because he is a murderer and you cannot really trust if parts that he says are true. He says about his guilt in killing the man but denies it.

What qualities of an unreliable narrator does Montresor show?

He is insulted by a man named Fortunato and vows to get revenge on him. Montresor reveals his inner thoughts and actions while slowly unfolding his plan that ultimately leads to the death of Fortunato. The character, Montresor, is an unreliable narrator because he is vindictive, manipulative, and cunning.

Is the narrator in The Cask of Amontillado reliable or unreliable?

In "The Cask of Amontillado," Montresor is an unreliable narrator because his mental state is questionable. In the beginning sentence, Montresor speaks in hyperbole: "The thousand injuries of Fortunato I had borne as best I could...." (Why would anyone bear so many injuries without have done something?)

23 related questions found

Why did Montresor wait 50 years?

Why did Montresor wait 50 years? In “The Cask of Amontillado,” Montresor waits fifty years before confessing to his horrendous crime in order to avoid punishment for murdering Fortunato.

(Video) "What is an Unreliable Narrator?": A Literary Guide for English Students and Teachers

Does Montresor feel guilty?

Throughout most of his evil deed against Fortunado, Montresor does not demonstrate any sense of guilt or regret. In fact, he seems to be rather enjoying himself and his diabolical plan. He teases Fortunado along, goading him and very cleverly manipulating the man to go further and further into the catacombs.

How do you know if a narrator is unreliable?

Signals of unreliable narration

  1. Intratextual signs such as the narrator contradicting himself, having gaps in memory, or lying to other characters.
  2. Extratextual signs such as contradicting the reader's general world knowledge or impossibilities (within the parameters of logic)
  3. Reader's literary competence.

Why does the narrator hate Fortunato?

Montresor hate Fortunato because he had been teasing Montresor and Montresor had had enough. Why does Montresor hate Fortunato? he thinks he had done nothing while Fortunato had been being mean to him and his family motto (Nemo me impune lacessit- No one attacks me with impunity) basically says he can.

How old is Montresor?

A positive attitude about the past is often observed in persons when they are old, and if he committed his perfect crime at about age 25, in the fictional present Montresor is 75 years old. Despite his age he appears healthy and vigorous and in no imminent danger of dying.

Why is Montresor mad at Fortunato?

The narrator, Montresor, is angry with Fortunato because he feels that Fortunato has injured and insulted him. ... It isn't hard to believe that Fortunato would be willing to insult Montresor, as we see him all too willing to do so during the story.

(Video) The Trial of Montresor

What did Montresor lie about?

Montresor tells the story and informs the reader of how well he planned his revenge on Fortunado. He admits that he lied to his servants "telling them that [he] should not return until the morning, and had given them explicit orders not to stir from the house".

What is Montresor's motive for killing Fortunato?

True to his family's motto, Montresor gets his revenge by burying Fortunato alive. In "The Cask of Amontillado," by Edgar Allan Poe, Montresor's motivation for killing Fortunato is simple: he was insulted.

What kind of man is Montresor?

Montresor is vengeful, obsessive, methodical, deceitful, manipulative, and merciless. Repaying Fortunato for an unnamed "insult" that is more important than the "thousand injuries" he has suffered at his hands becomes more than just an idle fantasy.

Who is Montresor telling the story to?

In "The Cask of Amontillado," Montresor may be telling the story to his priest.

Why does Montresor stop working?

Montresor stops working when Fortunato begins rattling his chains because Montresor a) is exhausted.

(Video) The Cask of Amontillado by Edgar Allan Poe – Thug Notes Summary & Analysis

Are Montresor and Fortunato friends?

Fortunato considers Montresor a friend, but not an important friend. He considers him a competitor but also a potential partner in business deals. They are really "friendly enemies." Fortunato has a similar relationship with Luchesi, who is only named but does not appear in the story.

At what point do you find Montresor most disturbing?

Montresor is the most disturbing when he leaves Fortunato behind while he is screaming. Montresor is disturbing during most of the story. At the beginning, he explains to us that he needs to kill a guy for a reason that is important to him but apparently not important enough to tell us.

Why does Montresor hide his hatred for Fortunato?

In "The Cask of Amontillado," we are never given a real reason as to why Montresor hates Fortunato. Montresor seems like a person who has no conscience and cares little about what he does to other people. He is just bent on revenge and takes all the necessary precautions to make sure he gets his revenge on Fortunato.

What type of narrator is unreliable?

An unreliable narrator is an untrustworthy storyteller, most often used in narratives with a first-person point of view. The unreliable narrator is either deliberately deceptive or unintentionally misguided, forcing the reader to question their credibility as a storyteller.

Which is the best example of an unreliable narrator?

The narrator who evades the truth out of self-preservation

(Video) Point of View/ Unreliable Narrator

A good example of this type of unreliable narrator is Pi Patel, the narrator of Yann Martel's Life of Pi. He tells a story of being adrift at sea and sharing his lifeboat with a zebra, orangutan, hyena, and tiger.

Is unreliable narrator good or bad?

Often, an unreliable narrator is a manipulator, a narcissist or a person who's losing (or has lost) her mind. But not every unreliable narrator is evil, dangerous, unhinged or even just plain unsympathetic.

Why did Montresor's heart grew sick?

Montresor does not experience satisfaction with the perfect crime he has committed. Instead he says: My heart grew sick; it was the dampness of the catacombs that made it so. He has called to Fortunato several times without getting a response.

Why does Montresor want other men to drink?

The real reason Montresor gives Fortunato the medoc is so he can get him drunker and more gullible. This way he can easily lure him into his trap of death without Fortunato suspecting anything throughout the scene.

What are three clever things Montresor does to lure Fortunato?

Finally, Montresor has to lure Fortunato into the lowest point in his home, the crypt. To do that, he feigns (pretends) concern for Fortunato's health and keeps giving him medicinal draughts of wine. This keeps Fortunato drunk or tipsy enough to keep moving without too many questions or hesitations.

FAQs

Is Montresor a reliable or unreliable narrator explain your answer? ›

Montresor is considered an unreliable narrator because his opinion of Fortunato is biased. Montresor feels greatly wronged by Fortunato, but the exact wrongdoing that Fortunato has committed is never clearly mentioned in the story.

Can you trust Montresor as the narrator? ›

Any critic will tell you that Montresor is “a classic example of an unreliable narrator.” And this is probably true: if he's capable of plastering Fortunato into a vault, we can't trust him. If he's lying, and he didn't kill Fortunato, then we still can't trust him.

What makes a narrator unreliable? ›

An unreliable narrator is an untrustworthy storyteller, most often used in narratives with a first-person point of view. The unreliable narrator is either deliberately deceptive or unintentionally misguided, forcing the reader to question their credibility as a storyteller.

What is an example of an unreliable narrator in The Cask of Amontillado? ›

Montresor is a perfect example of an unreliable narrator because he was capable of burying Fortunato into a vault. He vows revenge on Fortunato for an insult. He can't be trusted, even if he'd be lying about Fortunato's death. Fortunato´s name means ¨fortunate¨ which in reality, he didn 't really turn out that way.

What kind of narrator is Montresor? ›

First Person (Central Narrator) Montresor is our vile narrator. He is dedicated to his own point of view, which is cold, merciless, brutal, conniving, and vengeful. He doesn't mind telling us about his torture and murder of Fortunato; indeed, he thinks what he did was the just, right way to handle the situation.

Does The Cask of Amontillado have a reliable narrator? ›

In “The Cask of Amontillado” Edgar Allan Poe's narrator Montresor is unreliable because not only does he use verbal irony, but we only hear how the events unfolded from his point of view.

Was Montresor's revenge justified? ›

The definition of revenge is the act of doing something to hurt someone because that person did something that hurt you. The main character in the story, Montresor, explains his jealousy of Fortunato. To get revenge, he leads the other man to a slow death and seems to feel he is justified in this.

Who was the first unreliable narrator? ›

Image via Paramount. While one could argue that all narrators are unreliable to some degree, the first example of the term being used was in 1961 by Wayne C. Booth in his book on literary criticism called The Rhetoric of Fiction.

Which character is the best example of an unreliable narrator? ›

A good example of this type of unreliable narrator is Pi Patel, the narrator of Yann Martel's Life of Pi. He tells a story of being adrift at sea and sharing his lifeboat with a zebra, orangutan, hyena, and tiger.

What is the example of unreliable? ›

If you describe a person, machine, or method as unreliable, you mean that you cannot trust them. Diplomats can be a notoriously unreliable and misleading source of information. His judgement was unreliable. He had an unreliable car.

Is Montresor a woman? ›

Montresor: The Narrator in 'The Cask of Amontillado'

The story is narrated by Montresor, a man with a grudge. He claims that he has suffered many injuries from another man, Fortunato, but when he is finally insulted by Fortunato, Montresor decides it's time for revenge.

What miscommunication happened between Montresor and Fortunato? ›

What miscommunication happened between Montresor and Fortunato? In the end, Montresor regretted what he had done to Fortunato. Montressor planned on getting revenge on Fortunato, but had to wait until the time was right. The reader knows exactly what Fortunato did to cause such anger on Montresor.

What is it about Montresor that makes him such an effective villain in the story? ›

He is a fool to get caught in Montresor's trap. Montresor is an especially effective enemy to Fortunato because he acts like what? "A huge human foot d'or (of gold), in a field azure; the foot crushes a serpent (snake) rampant whose fangs are imbedded in the heel."

Is the narrator of The Cask of Amontillado reliable or unreliable? ›

In “The Cask of Amontillado” Edgar Allan Poe's narrator Montresor is unreliable because not only does he use verbal irony, but we only hear how the events unfolded from his point of view.

What makes Montresor sick? ›

At the end of the story, what makes Montresor feel sick? It's most likely a combination of the dampness of the tunnels and the nitre, or potassium nitrate, in the air. He does not feel sick about what he's done to Fortunato.

How does Montresor's point of view relate to the theme of The Cask of the Amontillado? ›

How does Montresor's point of view affect the theme in "The Cask of the Amontillado"?   His version of the story demonstrates that vengeful people cannot be trusted to see events clearly.

Why does Montresor want to seek revenge? ›

Montresor sought revenge on Fortunato because he had hurt Montresor for years, and now he has insulted him, and it has come to the final straw.

What textual evidence can you provide to show that Montresor is an unreliable narrator? ›

Now, Montresor is described as an unreliable narrator for a few main reasons. The main one is that Montresor is a murderer, and it's hard to trust someone who kills people especially when his only reason to kill Fortunato is that “he ventured upon insult” (Poe 107).

What kind of narrator is Montresor? ›

First Person (Central Narrator) Montresor is our vile narrator. He is dedicated to his own point of view, which is cold, merciless, brutal, conniving, and vengeful. He doesn't mind telling us about his torture and murder of Fortunato; indeed, he thinks what he did was the just, right way to handle the situation.

Was Montresor's revenge justified? ›

The definition of revenge is the act of doing something to hurt someone because that person did something that hurt you. The main character in the story, Montresor, explains his jealousy of Fortunato. To get revenge, he leads the other man to a slow death and seems to feel he is justified in this.

Why is Montresor name ironic? ›

Montresor's name suggests that he shows Fortunato his fate. We know that Montresor hates Fortunato, but Fortunato does not know about it. The condemned character is unaware that Montresor's friendly attitude is a pretense of good will, that his smile is at the thought of Fortunato's death.

How did Montresor feel after he killed Fortunato? ›

In conclusion, it's likely that Montresor felt some regret over his actions. The way he behaves in the story could be considered proof of that, and the fact that Montresor could be confessing his actions fifty years later to someone makes it seems like he regrets what he did.

Did Montresor succeed in killing Fortunato? ›

Answer and Explanation: In 'The Cask of Amontillado,' Montresor kills Fortunato by building a wall around him in the depths of the wine cellar/ catacombs, sealing him inside. Montresor has plotted and planned his revenge against Fortunato.

What is the moral lesson of The Cask of Amontillado? ›

Revenge is a central theme in "The Cask of Amontillado". Montresor feels very disrespected when Fortunato insults him and, as a result of that, Montresor vows revenge: “The thousand injuries of Fortunato I had borned as best I could; but when he ventured upon insult, I vowed revenge.” (Poe 1117).

What is the message of the story The Cask of Amontillado? ›

The Cask of Amontillado by Edgar Poe, he sends a message that revenge may blind the eye towards happiness. In the beginning of the story Montresor shows that he is planning revenge on Fortunato and that is the only thing on Montresor mind.

What reason does the narrator give that Fortunato should turn back? ›

The Cask of Amontillado: Unfortunato True or False
1.What does Fortunato keep getting as he follows the narrator? -> Drunker True False
2.What reason does the narrator give that Fortunato should turn back? -> He is too sick to be in such a damp place True False
3 more rows

How did Montresor trick Fortunato? ›

He tricks Fortunato into accompanying him into the catacombs by saying that he would ask Luchesi to taste the Amontillado because he was concerned that Fortunato has a cold. Montresor suggests that the damp walls will make Fortunato ill. But Fortunato insists on going with Montresor to taste the Amontillado.

What kind of man is Montresor? ›

Montressor is a manipulative and vengeful person. These characteristics lead to the death of Fortunato, a man who has wronged him. Through the acts, words, and thoughts of the character, one is able to see him carry out his plan for revenge.

What did Fortunato pride himself on? ›

He prides himself on his connoisseurship in wine” (116). Interestingly, Montresor sees Fortunato's pride as a weakness, but he sees his own as a strength. Like the clever man he is, Montresor preys upon this point, creating a nonexistent cask of Amontillado that he knows Fortunato will do anything to taste.

Videos

1. The Cask of Amontillado by Edgar Allan Poe | Summary & Analysis
(Course Hero)
2. PoV + Narrator in Poe's "Cask of Amontillado"
(Lisette Blanco-Cerda)
3. "What is Irony?": A Literary Guide for English Students and Teachers
(Oregon State University - School of Writing, Literature and Film)
4. Building the Outline (and also an Introduction to the LA)
(Haley Nix)
5. Learning to Write Horror from Edgar Allan Poe (Reading and Analysis of “The Cask of Amontillado”)
(Diane Callahan - Quotidian Writer)
6. The Regis Thesis
(Regis English)

Top Articles

You might also like

Latest Posts

Article information

Author: Moshe Kshlerin

Last Updated: 09/07/2022

Views: 5898

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (57 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Moshe Kshlerin

Birthday: 1994-01-25

Address: Suite 609 315 Lupita Unions, Ronnieburgh, MI 62697

Phone: +2424755286529

Job: District Education Designer

Hobby: Yoga, Gunsmithing, Singing, 3D printing, Nordic skating, Soapmaking, Juggling

Introduction: My name is Moshe Kshlerin, I am a gleaming, attractive, outstanding, pleasant, delightful, outstanding, famous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.